Civil War 3971
Saturday, May 31, 2008-2:40 A.M.
Good morning from Charleston, West Virginia. I'm getting ready to sack out after my grueling one-show evening here at the Comedy Zone (Hi, Heff and Joel!) in the Ramada Inn. I'm working with one of my favorite comics to share a stage with, Detroit's Jef Brannan. If you've never seen Jef on stage, he's what John Hiatt would look and sound like if Hiatt did standup comedy. Or, Hiatt is what Jef would sound like if he really wanted to be a musician....either description fits.
The tour started Thursday night in Prestonsburg, Kentucky, at the Prestonsburg Inn, formerly the Best Western, formerly the Holiday Inn. My day started out on a positive note; I had left the power cord to my sleep apnea breathing apparatus (CPAP if you're familiar) at the hotel in Matthews, North Carolina and they found it and next-day mailed it to me (I had contacted them and given them my credit card number to pay for postage). I got it just as I was leaving my house at 8 A.M. I was happy to have it (even though the power cord for my laptop was an exact match and I'd been using it in the other cord's absence) until I found out that FedEx next day first delivery cost $64. I probably could have purchased five replacement cords for that much, but ultimately I'm thankful that the hotel went to the trouble of getting me the cord as quickly as humanly possible, as it was for a medical device and they probably felt it was quite urgent. They could have told me to go pound rock salt, but they didn't. And really, it was my fault for packing my luggage in haste and forgetting the cord, so I've learned a lesson about taking my time and being thorough.
The ride to Kentucky was just under ten hours, with rest stops and bathroom breaks. I ball parked the trip as being shorter, but left early just in case. After 20 years of doing comedy, I've developed a "Rule of the Road," and that rule is: On Every Road Trip, A Shoe Will Drop (something will go wrong) And If You Can Get Over That, Everything Else Will Be Fine. For this trip, the "shoe" was me forgetting to pack shaving cream....and that's not even a shoe at all, because most hotels have little travel size shaving creams that they'll give you in case you forgot yours. The hotel in Prestonsburg had the nice stuff, too...a two-ounce container of Gillette Foamy. Some hotels cheap out and give you the stuff in the little foil packet that you have to lather up and put on your face...it's a bunk product, the kind that you find in the dollar store when you're in there looking for a bargain and you hypnotize yourself into thinking that some piece of crap is worth a dollar because you don't want to come out of the store empty-handed.
So I got over my little shoe drop, and today, Jef and I went out in search of a place that would cash our paychecks. The hotel, under the previous ownership, banked locally and cashing the checks wasn't a problem. The new owners are banking out of a place in Lexington, Kentucky, read: nowhere near where we were. We got sent to Wal-Mart, who then refused to cash the checks because the checks were hand-written. Now, I'm sure that this was to prevent taking a bum check that was a forgery, but all it did was shove us to a grocery store. We drove around for almost half an hour looking for the store we got sent to, but we found it (Food City) and they happily cashed our checks for a $5 fee (Wal-Mart would have charge $3). I gassed up at their pumps, happily paying $3.93 a gallon and noting that the gas prices locally had actually seemed to go down by about six cents a gallon since the day before.
We grabbed some Chinese buffet lunch and Jef, ever the class act, picked up the lunch tab. There are still some old-time road dogs out there that adhere to the custom of the headliner taking the feature out to lunch one day on the tour. I get the opportunity to close more frequently these days and I relish the opportunity to take the middle (or emcee) to lunch....I feel like I'm passing some sort of torch, and that there's some nobility in that. We got into Charleston after a long delay due to construction on Interstate 64, I feel like I sat in slow-moving traffic for about an hour, and a two-hour trip turned into three just like that. The torture of being stuck in traffic is that there are limited things you can do to pass the time. I made a couple of business phone calls and booked some work, so the time wasn't a total loss, but even my big pack 'o CD's couldn't entertain me, so I turned to talk radio.
Now, talk radio does nothing but get my blood boiling, because I can't believe the things that some people think and feel about the world around us. Yesterday, there was a topic that was being talked about as I drove through Ohio and heard some of the local hosts discussing regarding two students who were also National Guard or Army reserve members, and they wanted to wear their dress uniforms to graduation, and the school didn't want them to do that, they wanted them to wear traditional gowns like everyone else, saying that uniforms would be a distraction.
Now, I'm just a simple guy from Rochester, NY....Rochester's a town big enough that Hee Haw wouldn't give us a salute, but folks from the Big Apple scoff and say that we're a bunch of hicks. I wouldn't trade my hometown for most out there, and I feel that I've done pretty well by being raised with a little common sense and enough access to book learning to form intelligent decisions about things.
The way I think about the issue is this; anytime the word "military" enters the discussion, people get a little emotional, and rightly so-we are in a war right now, and a lot of people feel very strongly about that war one way or the other. So when a kid says "I want to wear my military uniform to graduation," no matter what side of the argument you land on, it's not about tradition, or freedom of speech, IT'S ABOUT THE WAR. And I guess the educational institution, I gotta guess it's a college, doesn't want to validate the war by letting these students wear their dress uniforms.
The specific court ruling on this sort of thing specifies that a student does not relinquish their freedom of speech at the schoolhouse door. Now, I guess things are different if it's a public school versus a private institution that the two soldier-graduates are attending. If it's a public school, and you attend at the pleasure of the city, county or state, then I feel you should tow the line and dress like everyone else if that’s the rule as it is applied to everyone. But if it's a private school and you're paying your tuition, then you have rights that come with your receipt and wearing a dress uniform is your prerogative. Would two students in dress military garb detract from the graduation ceremony? Hell, no. I will say this; I wouldn't want to be the poor civilian student who had to cross the stage after one of the soldiers, because you're going to have to stand there and wait while a standing ovation occurs. Supporting the troops means clapping your hands and voicing approval loudly so everyone can see you doing it....people need validation all the time, particularly when their patriotism could be questioned. And if you stay in your seat while the soldier-student in his dress uniform crosses the stage, then the terrorists have won.
Seriously, has anyone mentioned a compromise in all of this? Our country was built on compromises, the ability to sit down and acknowledge each others' differences of opinion and give a little to get a little bit of what we want. Maybe the soldiers could wear their uniforms, but go across the stage together either first or last, so that the bulk of the graduating class could conduct the traditional ceremony without interruption. Or maybe the soldiers could be sat down and convinced that this particular ceremony does not represent their service to their country but rather their individual achievement, and that they would be welcome to wear their dress uniforms under their graduation gowns? Either way, it sounds like emotions have been allowed to come between civil discourse and disagreement.
One of the topics of the last two days that has caught my attention is a report out of the Pentagon that last year, over 100 soldiers committed suicide. 75% of those soldiers were home from Iraq, 25% of them killed themselves while in country. All but four of the soldiers were men.
This is disturbing to me. I'm deeply resentful of the United States' mission in Iraq. I feel, as an observer who only gets his information from media sources, that Iraq is taking advantage of the United States and allowing our soldiers to do the heavy lifting. And all that heavy lifting is starting to take its toll. For a soldier to complete his tour of duty, come home, and then put a gun in his own mouth and pull the trigger, or hang himself, or take a bottle of sleeping pills with a big glass of whiskey and settle into a nice, warm tub of water, is morbid and distressing to me. If I'm a parent and my son (or daughter) is serving in Iraq, and they die from an improved explosive device, or killed in a firefight, or whatever ghastly death war can bring a young person, I'm devastated. But if my son or daughter comes home and takes their own life, and I knowthat there are a hundred others doing the same thing? Then I need to start asking questions, and question number one is "What the fuck is going on over there?" I was pissed off when I heard that our troops were digging through trash piles for scrap metal to up-armor their vehicles, and now this. Really, if we want to support our troops, maybe the only real way to support them is to get 'em the hell out of there, and pronto.
Fuck those yellow ribbons. I hate to see those ribbon magnets on cars and trucks driving around, because it represents to me the false, numbing patriotism that passes for real patriotism in our country today. A yellow ribbon never stopped a guy from getting blown up by a booby-trap, never stopped a bullet from catching him in the head, never stopped him from succumbing to despair so deep and bleak that the only escape was self-termination.
I'd like to think that I was taught better, when I was a kid. I was a Cub Scout, and we learned things, like how to properly fold a flag, but more importantly, the sense of community and civic duty that being an American was all about. We were taught to be proud of our country and our freedoms, and to be charitable and kind, respectful and dignified. We saluted the flag and stood on ceremony, and we were active in our community, doing the work of being Americans and making a difference.
Those lessons never left me. A few years ago, I was heading back to my car after picking up a couple of fish-fry dinners for my family, and an old lady asked my help to cross a busy intersection. I gave her my arm without hesitation; I always learned to respect my elders. I'm embarrassed to share this, because my little rant isn't about me, but some of the folks in their cars stopped at the intersection and clapped for me as I helped this woman to the other side of the street. But I didn't do it for that reason; I did it because it was the right thing to do. Our soldiers serve because it's the right thing to do. And it's certainly o.k. to applaud them; they definitely do more than help old ladies across the street. But yellow ribbons and squabbling over dress uniforms at a graduation honors no one, and worse than that, it deepens the rift that already splits our country in two.
The vibe here in West Virginia and Kentucky (very similar, the two states) is that of many rural communities and to a greater extent, the Southeast. The yellow ribbon is resplendent everywhere as feathers on a peacock, and to me, just as phony as a Jesus fish on your car.
Y’see, to me, it’s like this; if you’ve got Jesus in your heart, you don’t need to put a fish on your car. When I was a kid attending Catholic Church and going to CCD classes on Sunday, we sang songs that said “They will know we are Christians by our love.” They didn’t say anything about Jesus fish on the car. The Jesus fish is phony, and the Bible says as much; the scripture says “Don’t pray in the street like the Pharisees, do it in your closet” where it’s just between you and the Lord.
I feel patriotism is the same thing. I don’t need to see a flag pin on somebody’s lapel to know that they love our country, and I don’t need to see a yellow ribbon on a car to know that they support our troops. If you want to show me, don’t tell me….what you do will speak so loudly I won’t hear what you’re saying. One night on talk radio, the guest on the show was an officer of the U.S.O. and he took a call from a woman who wanted to knit mittens for the troops in Iraq. The U.S.O. office politely reminded the woman that Iraq was a desert and that mittens wouldn’t necessarily have been the most needed article of clothing. But that’s what I’m talking about; show me, don’t tell me. I’ve got buddies who have gone to Iraq to entertain the troops and bring a little laughter into their lives over there. THAT’s supporting the troops. I hear stories about kids doing CD and DVD drives to send stuff to the troops for them to listen to and watch on their down time. THAT’s supporting the troops. Jesus, maybe somebody could send one of these poor guys a letter, be a pen pal, let them vent about what’s bothering them? THAT would be supporting the troops.
Or, you could just buy a yellow ribbon (made in China) and put it on your car next to your Jesus fish, 6,000 miles away from Iraq and support the troops that way.
But the fear for these ribbon-toting folks is that if they don’t sport the ribbon, they must not support the troops. And that would be akin to high treason. And didn’t the yellow ribbon start in support of the American hostages in Iran, back in the late 1970’s? The irony there is so thick, you could up-armor a Humvee with it.
Let me mention this, should anyone misinterpret what I’ve written. I want to be very, very clear. This nation was founded on dissent. Disagreement. Ideological differences. The whole shootin’ match was started because our founding fathers didn’t agree with the rule of Britain, and so they decided to start off on their own. And when they did, they wrote the Constitution. And in the Constitution, in the First Amendment, they guaranteed freedom of speech. The wanted, first and foremost, for all Americans to feel free to speak their minds, because dissent is healthy as a continuous test of government and policy, to guarantee that the will of the people steer the rudder and that self-government is assured. And yet disagreement in this country has become the magnet to allegations of everything from treason to the highest insult of all, “You don’t support our troops.” It is a weak argument to begin with, and unfounded. It is only a half-step above name-calling. And it is pitiable that it is used so frequently.
One of the reasons why this faulty logic is not only arrived at but perpetuated, particularly in the rural areas of our country and to a large part, the southeastern states, is that there is no dissenting viewpoint being represented. You cannot have an argument, and when I say argument, I don’t mean “fight,” I mean “discussion designed to accommodate contrary viewpoints in the effort to persuade or educate,” if only one side shows up.
And in these aforementioned areas of the United States, there’s only one side showing up.
150 years ago, the reasons for this were obvious; the South was largely agrarian, the North largely industrialized. And education was more accessible in the North, as the people were not slaves to the agricultural calendar as they were in the South. So education in the South was actually inculcation, with a great deal of religious instruction taking the place of analytical thought, scientific method or philosophical litmus tests of any kind.
Consider the arguments for and against abortion; if you completely eliminate the religious aspect of the argument, you have nothing left to argue against abortion being safe and legal. Religiosity has taken the place of clear and analytical thinking. I look at this way; if two water-heads couldn’t figure out a condom in the backseat of a car on prom night, do I really want them raising children? The answer is NO. But I don’t allow my religious views to encumber my ability to pragmatically analyze how I feel about public policy. I would never abort a child that I had a hand in conceiving, but I would never stop another couple from making the decision that suits their morals and ethics best. I would be denying them the same freedom that I enjoy, and that’s un-American.
Some of my closest friends have called me elitist in my thinking, but I have to disagree; I am the son of a blue-collar man, I attended public schools my whole life, and labored four years to earn a two-year degree. I think that my intelligence may be eclipsed by my laziness, or I might have achieved more, but basically what I’m trying to say is that I am intellectually no better than anyone else. Everything I’ve learned, I’ve learned at the knee of teachers who taught the masses and I had no better resources than anyone else. I’ve only taken the time to exploit those resources to my best advantage, and encourage everyone I’ve ever met or known to do the same. Ultimately, I fear that a new kind of civil war is due in this country, the kind of a war that doesn’t pit Americans against each other based on the geographical location of their home, but a war that pits Liberal against Conservative, intellectual versus emotional, pragmatic against dogmatic. And I don’t know how it will turn out because the intellectuals will have better strategies and planning, but the emotional folks will have more guns.
Bottom line, we need a national wake-up call, and we need it quick. America doesn’t have the luxury that the European nations have. Nations like France, Germany, Spain and others have the advantage of small geographical areas and condensed populations. It doesn’t take long to have a consensus and except for some fine points on implementation and policy, they can get things done quickly and at the pleasure of whole group. In our country, we’ve got deep emotional scarring over college football allegiances (Michigan vs. Ohio State, Alabama vs. Tennessee). Our country is big enough that it could be split five ways easy, our viewpoints are so diversified.
Thinking about this stuff is ripping me up on a daily basis, because as an American I yearn for our country to heal, and as a comic, I have to travel around the country, look at the pain and then try to extract humor from it. And we seem far from healing, as long as we squabble about uniforms and flag pins, yellow ribbons and patriotism.
God Bless America.
Ralph Tetta
Rochester, NY